Dylan Strome and Ivan Lodnia both scored in the shootout as the Otters topped the Spitfires 5- 4 for their 10th straight win.
Alex DeBrincat, Warren Foegele, Lodnia and Kyle Maksimovich supplied the offence in regulation for Erie (39-10-3).
Gabriel Vilardi and Jeremy Bracco both struck twice for the Spitfires (33-13-8).
The Spitfires are now tied for fourth in the Conference with Owen Sound, although the Attack have two games in hand.
Windsor's also three points behind the Soo in the fight for first in the West Division.
The Spits will take on Sarnia Thursday night at the WFCU Centre.